Who Can Be a Legal Representative of a Deceased Under Indian Law?

Trusted Legal Guidance by Vivek Nasa & Associates – Gurugram’s Leading Civil and Property Law Firm

When a litigant passes away during an ongoing civil proceeding, it raises crucial legal questions regarding the continuation of the case. Indian law, particularly the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (CPC), provides a structured legal framework to determine who qualifies as a "Legal Representative" in such situations. Supreme Court precedents further clarify the responsibilities and liabilities of these representatives.

At Vivek Nasa & Associates, we specialize in civil litigation, property disputes, inheritance laws, estate administration, and business law in Gurugram. This article explores legal provisions governing legal representatives, their role in executing decrees, and their liability in civil cases.

The Legal Doctrine: "Action Personalismoritur Cum Persona"

It is an established legal principle that certain claims die with the individual. This is encapsulated in the Latin maxim "action personalismoritur cum persona"—meaning, "a personal right of action dies with the person." However, there are exceptions where the principle does not apply, such as:

1. Defamation cases

2. Criminal proceedings involving personal injury (excluding murder)

3. Cases where relief in a suit becomes futile due to a party's demise

However, when a judgment debtor dies before satisfying a money decree, the decree holder may move the court to execute the decree against the deceased’s legal representatives or heirs. That said, when a judgment debtor dies before fully satisfying a money decree, the decree holder can approach the court that passed the decree to seek execution against the legal representatives or heirs of the deceased judgment debtor. In such situations, the aforementioned common law principle does not apply. Now we will analyze  liabilities in property disputes, business litigations, and inheritance-related cases in Gurugram.

Definition of Legal Representative Under CPC - Who Qualifies as a Legal Representative? 

Section 2(11) of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908, defines a "legal representative" as:

The CPC defines a legal representative as:

"A person who in law represents the estate of a deceased person, and includes any person who intermeddles with the estate of the deceased, and where a party sues or is sued in a representative character, the person on whom the estate devolves on the death of the party so suing or sued.""

This definition establishes that legal representation is not limited to heirs and may extend to persons managing the deceased’s estate, It extends beyond legal heirs and may include executors, administrators, intermeddlers, or successors in a representative role.

Categories of Legal Representatives in Civil Cases

Based on statutory interpretation and judicial pronouncements, the following persons may qualify as legal representatives:

1. Legal Heirs (Succession Law & Property Disputes)

The primary legal representatives of a deceased litigant are their heirs as per succession laws applicable to them (Hindu Succession Act, 1956 for Hindus; Indian Succession Act, 1925 for Christians and Parsis; and Muslim Personal Law for Muslims).

• Governed by the Hindu Succession Act, 1956, Indian Succession Act, 1925, or Muslim Personal Law, as applicable.

• In Kasturi v. Iyyamperumal (2005) 6 SCC 733, the Supreme Court held that all legal heirs are necessary parties to litigation upon the death of a litigant.

2. Executors and Administrators (Estate Planning & Probate Matters)

• If the deceased left a will, the executor named in the will takes legal responsibility.

• If no executor is appointed, an administrator appointed under the Indian Succession Act, 1925, can act as a legal representative.

• In Krishna Kumar Birla v. Rajendra Singh Lodha (2008) 4 SCC 300, the Supreme Court held that an executor has priority over heirs in estate administration matters.

3. Intermeddlers with the Estate (Illegal Possession & Estate Disputes)

• Even if not a legal heir, a person who intermeddles with the estate of the deceased may be deemed a legal representative under Section 2(11) CPC.

• In N.K. Mohd. Sulaiman Sahib v. N.C. Mohd. Ismail Sahib (1966) AIR 792 SC, the Supreme Court observed that a person actively handling the estate affairs of a deceased can be impleaded as a legal representative.

4. Successors in a Representative Role (Business Disputes & HUF Cases)

• If the deceased was suing or being sued in a representative capacity (e.g., trustee, karta of a Hindu Undivided Family), the successor in that role becomes the legal representative.

• In Sital Prasad Saxena v. Kedar Nath (1982) AIR 119, the Court ruled that a succeeding karta of an HUF continues the litigation.

5. Government in Escheat Cases (Unclaimed Property & Inheritance)

• If a deceased’s estate escheats to the government (under the doctrine of escheat), the government can be treated as a legal representative.

• In State of Punjab v. Balwant Singh (1991) 4 SCC 32, the Supreme Court upheld the government's right to defend its claim to an escheated estate. 

Liability of Legal Representatives in Execution of Decrees

Section 50(1) CPC allows a decree holder to seek execution against legal heirs of a deceased judgment debtor. This provision allows for execution against Class I and Class II heirs by filing an application before the court that issued the decree.

However, Section 50(2) limits liability only to the extent of inherited property, stating that legal representatives are only accountable to the extent of the property they inherit from the deceased. Additionally, requires the court to determine whether a person qualifies as a legal representative before impleading them. Section 47(3) CPC further empowers the executing court to decide such matters.

Judicial Observations on the Liability of Legal Representatives

1. Andhra Bank v. N. Srinivasan – Held that a deceased's liability survives through their legal estate, but representatives are liable only for inherited assets. The Supreme Court cited Salmond’s Jurisprudence, noting that a deceased judgment debtor’s legal personality survives for purposes of satisfying debts. It clarified that a legal representative’s liability is limited to the extent of the property inherited from the deceased 

2. Ambili Devi v. Kerala State Road Transport Corporation – Spousal employment benefits are not subject to attachment for the deceased's debt. The Kerala High Court ruled that a widow employed on compassionate grounds could not have her salary attached to settle her deceased husband's debts.

3. Jaladi Suguna v. Satya Sai Central Trust – The court must assess a legal representative’s liability before impleading them. The Supreme Court held that an application to implead legal representatives does not automatically establish liability. The court must assess whether the individual inherited assets from the deceased.

4. Pannalal v. Mst Naraini – Legal heirs cannot be held liable for ancestral debt under Hindu Law without due hearing. The Supreme Court emphasized that legal representatives cannot be held liable for debts under Hindu Law without being given a fair hearing.

5. Prabhakara Adiga v. Gowri – The Court ruled that Section 50 CPC applies to all types of decrees, including injunctions. 

Conclusion: Protecting Your Rights in Civil Litigation

Legal representatives play a critical role in civil litigation, property disputes, inheritance cases, and business law matters. However, courts do not automatically impose liability on legal heirs unless they have inherited the deceased’s assets.

At Vivek Nasa & Associates, we provide expert legal services in property law, civil litigation, estate administration, and business disputes in Gurugram. If you need assistance with:

• Legal representation in property disputes

• Inheritance and succession matters

• Estate planning and probate litigation

• Civil and business litigation services

1. Why is Vivek Nasa & Associates considered the best law firm for property and business disputes in Gurugram?

Vivek Nasa & Associates is a leading law firm in Gurugram known for its expertise in property disputes, inheritance claims, civil litigation, and corporate law. Our firm provides strategic legal solutions, expert courtroom representation, and personalized legal counsel for businesses and individuals.

2. What types of property disputes does Vivek Nasa & Associates handle?

We specialize in resolving property title disputes, builder-buyer conflicts, illegal possession cases, property fraud, will disputes, and partition suits. Our firm ensures quick legal remedies for residential, commercial, and industrial property issues in Gurugram.

3. Can Vivek Nasa & Associates help with inheritance and succession disputes?

Yes, we handle inheritance disputes, succession certificate claims, estate planning, and will execution. We assist clients in ensuring smooth asset transfer and legal heirship claims under Hindu Succession Act, Indian Succession Act, and personal laws.

4. What are the legal services offered for business disputes in Gurugram?

We offer corporate legal solutions, including:

• Contract disputes and breach of agreements.

• Partnership and shareholder conflicts.

• Intellectual property (IP) rights and trademark disputes.

• Debt recovery and commercial litigation.

• Arbitration and alternative dispute resolution (ADR).
  
  

5. How does Vivek Nasa & Associates handle real estate litigation?

We provide comprehensive legal solutions for real estate transactions and litigation, including:

• Title verification & due diligence before purchase.

• Property fraud and forgery disputes.

• Landlord-tenant conflicts and eviction cases.

• RERA complaints against builders for delayed possession.

6. Who can be a legal representative in a civil case under Indian law?

A legal representative under Indian law is any person who legally represents the estate of a deceased individual. As per Section 2(11) of the Code of Civil Procedure (CPC), 1908, this includes legal heirs, executors, administrators, or any person who intermeddles with the estate of the deceased.

7. What happens to a civil case when a litigant dies in India?

If a party to a civil case dies, the case does not automatically abate. Order 22 of the CPC allows the legal representatives to continue or defend the case. The court decides the substitution of legal representatives to ensure continuity.

8. How does the Code of Civil Procedure define a legal representative?

According to Section 2(11) of CPC, a legal representative includes:

• Legal heirs (Class I and II under Hindu Succession Act, 1956).

• Executors/Administrators of a Will.

• Persons intermeddling with the deceased’s estate.

• Legal guardians in case of minor heirs.
  
  

9. Can a legal heir automatically become a legal representative in court proceedings?

No, legal heirs do not automatically become legal representatives. The court determines who can represent the deceased’s estate in a lawsuit. The heir must file an application under Order 22 Rule 3 or 4 of CPC.

10. What is the legal process for appointing a representative after a party’s death in a lawsuit?

The legal heirs must file an application within 90 days of the litigant’s death, seeking substitution. The court will assess the claim and, if satisfied, appoint the legal representative. Delay in application can lead to abatement of the suit.

11. What is the legal doctrine of ‘action personalismoritur cum persona’ in Indian law?

This Latin maxim means "a personal action dies with the person." It applies to certain cases like defamation or personal injury claims. However, money decrees and property-related claims survive and can be enforced against legal representatives.

12. Can a legal representative continue a pending lawsuit on behalf of the deceased?

Yes, if a legal representative is appointed, the case continues. The representative can defend, contest, or settle the case on behalf of the deceased’s estate.

13. What are the rights of a legal representative in civil litigation?

A legal representative has the right to:

• Continue or defend the lawsuit.

• Settle claims on behalf of the estate.

• Receive benefits or enforce rights from the case.
  
  

14. Under what circumstances can the government act as a legal representative?

If a deceased person has no legal heirs or Will, the government may take over the estate under doctrine of escheat, as per the Hindu Succession Act, 1956.

15. What are the key Supreme Court judgments related to legal representatives in India?

• Andhra Bank v. N. Srinivasan – Established that legal representatives are liable only to the extent of inherited property.

• Jaladi Suguna (Deceased) Through LRs vs. Satya Sai Central Trust – Legal representatives must be verified before impleadment.

• Pannalal v. Mst. Naraini – Sons cannot be held liable for their father’s debts without an opportunity to be heard.
  
  

16. How does succession law impact the appointment of a legal representative?

Succession laws (Hindu Succession Act, Indian Succession Act) determine who qualifies as a legal heir, which impacts who can be appointed as a legal representative in a lawsuit.

17. Can a legal representative challenge the deceased’s liabilities in court?

Yes, legal representatives can contest unjust liabilities. Courts assess whether the debt or liability is legally enforceable before execution.

18. What legal steps should heirs take if a deceased family member was involved in litigation?

• File an application under Order 22 Rule 3 or 4 of CPC.

• Submit relevant succession documents or Will.

• Consult legal experts like Vivek Nasa & Associates for proper representation in Gurugram courts.
  
  

19. Is court permission required to substitute a legal representative in a civil case?

Yes, the court must approve the substitution of a legal representative. The opposing party can challenge the appointment if there is a dispute.

20. How can Vivek Nasa & Associates help in property and inheritance disputes in Gurugram?

Vivek Nasa & Associates, a trusted property and business law firm in Gurugram, offers:

• Legal representation in civil disputes involving inheritance and succession.

• Expert advice on property claims and money decrees.

• Court litigation services to enforce or defend legal rights.

• Succession planning and Will drafting to secure estates.

21. What are the best legal remedies for a delayed possession case against a builder?

We assist in filing cases under:

• RERA Act, 2016 for compensation and possession.

• Consumer Protection Act, 2019 for refunds and damages.

• Civil suit for breach of contract against the builder.
  
  

22. How does Vivek Nasa & Associates assist NRIs with property disputes in India?

We provide legal representation for NRIs in property litigation, title clearance, and illegal possession cases. Our team ensures a hassle-free legal process for overseas clients.

23. What is the process of obtaining a succession certificate in Gurugram?

The process involves:

1. Filing a petition in District Court.

2. Submitting legal heir documents and proof of assets.

3. Publication of notice for objections.

4. Grant of succession certificate by the court.
   
   

24. Can Vivek Nasa & Associates help in partnership disputes and business dissolution?

Yes, we assist in:

• Dissolution of partnerships and business settlements.

• Contract enforcement and breach resolution.

• Arbitration and litigation for corporate conflicts.
  
  

25. What are the most common inheritance disputes in India?

• Disputed Wills and forged documents.

• Unequal property distribution among heirs.

• Legal heirship claims in joint family properties.

• Nominee vs. Legal Heir conflicts in financial assets.
  
  

26. What legal services does Vivek Nasa & Associates offer for startups in Gurugram?

We provide startup legal consulting, company registration, contract drafting, trademark protection, and investor agreement support.

27. How long does it take to resolve a property dispute in Gurugram?

It depends on the complexity of the case. Mediation and out-of-court settlements can take 3-6 months, while court litigation may take 1-5 years, depending on the evidence and legal procedures.

28. Can a property dispute be resolved without going to court?

Yes, disputes can be resolved through mediation, arbitration, or settlement agreements, which are legally binding and avoid lengthy court proceedings.

29. How does Vivek Nasa & Associates ensure the best legal strategy for clients?

Our firm follows a client-centric approach, offering:

• Tailored legal strategies for each case.

• In-depth legal research and case analysis.

• Expert negotiation and courtroom advocacy.

• Transparent communication and timely updates.
  
  

30. How can I book a consultation with Vivek Nasa & Associates?

You can schedule a consultation by:

• Calling our office in Gurugram.

• Filling out our online inquiry form on our website.

• Visiting our law firm for a direct consultation.

31. What is the process to file a property dispute case in Gurugram?

The process includes:

1. Legal consultation to assess the dispute.

2. Drafting and filing a legal notice to the opposing party.

3. Filing a suit in civil court under property laws.

4. Court proceedings and settlement negotiations.
   
   

32. Can Vivek Nasa & Associates help with Will registration and estate planning?

Yes, we provide estate planning, will drafting, registration, and probate litigation services. Our lawyers ensure legal compliance and smooth property succession for families in Gurugram.

33. How do I resolve a family property dispute legally?

You can file a partition suit or seek mediation/arbitration. Our firm specializes in amicable settlements and strong legal representation to resolve family property conflicts efficiently.

34. What legal steps should I take if my property is illegally occupied?

• File a police complaint for trespassing.

• Issue a legal notice to the occupant.

• File a civil suit for possession and injunction in court.

• Seek police or court-mandated eviction if necessary.
  
  

35. Does Vivek Nasa & Associates offer corporate legal advisory for businesses in Gurugram?

Yes, we provide business legal consulting, contract drafting, compliance advisory, and dispute resolution for startups, SMEs, and multinational corporations operating in Gurugram.

36. Are all legal heirs considered legal representatives in a civil dispute?

No, only those heirs who have a direct legal interest in the litigation or have inherited the deceased’s estate can be considered legal representatives. The court verifies the claim before appointing a representative.

37. What is the difference between an executor, administrator, and legal representative?

• Executor: Appointed by the deceased through a Will to execute the estate.

• Administrator: Appointed by the court when there is no Will.

• Legal Representative: Any person legally entitled to represent the deceased in legal proceedings.
  
  

38. Can someone who is not a family member be appointed as a legal representative?

Yes, if a person has been named in a Will or has a significant legal interest in the deceased’s estate (such as a trustee or executor), they may be appointed as a legal representative.

39. What is the liability of legal representatives in executing a deceased person's money decree?

Under Section 50 of CPC, legal representatives are liable to the extent of the deceased’s estate that has come into their hands. They are not personally liable beyond the inherited property.

40. Can a legal representative be held personally liable for the deceased’s debts?

No, legal representatives are not personally liable for the debts of the deceased. They are only responsible for paying off debts from the deceased’s estate, as per Section 50(2) of CPC.